Navigation: Main Page » Computer / Recreational / Science / Society / Television
 
Web N-N-A.com
         
Recreational Groups Forum Index  »  Audio - Car Audio  »  8" 10" or 12"...which one?
Page 1 of 1    
Author Message
sims
Posted: Sun Nov 16, 2008 5:22 pm
Guest
just looking for a little kick in the back of my jimmy, and not trying to
break the bank.

I noticed I can get a 10" or a 12" with the exact same specs
(watts/rms/ohms) but was wondering what would be the benefit to using a
larger sub?
ChrisB
Posted: Sun Nov 16, 2008 5:22 pm
Guest
sims wrote:
Quote:
just looking for a little kick in the back of my jimmy, and not trying
to break the bank.

I noticed I can get a 10" or a 12" with the exact same specs
(watts/rms/ohms) but was wondering what would be the benefit to using a
larger sub?



A larger subwoofer will generally give you a deeper bass output when

comparing the same mfg/model/line of sub. With that said, deep bass
output is highly dependent on how well your subwoofer enclosure is mated
to your subwoofer.

Just keep in mind that not every subwoofer is created equally and some
brands are WAY better than others, except JL Audio. Don't get me wrong,
JL Audio is expensive for a reason and that is because their Quality
Control standards are overboard. I am just saying there are subwoofers
that sound almost as good as JL Audio for a lost less $$!
sims
Posted: Mon Nov 17, 2008 5:34 am
Guest
what companies would you compare to JL? I was interested in them only since
the shop told me to go with them. I am not expierenced with brands to
quality in car audio, but I must say I was impressed with JL.
I was at another place tonight and they sell MTX, rockford, infinity, and
JBL. the salesman recommended the infinity, but also noted his car is
loaded with JL...



"ChrisB" <ChrisB@somewhere.someplace.com> wrote in message
news:BtWdnbixyvdi2b3UnZ2dnUVZ_vCdnZ2d@giganews.com...
Quote:
sims wrote:
just looking for a little kick in the back of my jimmy, and not trying to
break the bank.

I noticed I can get a 10" or a 12" with the exact same specs
(watts/rms/ohms) but was wondering what would be the benefit to using a
larger sub?



A larger subwoofer will generally give you a deeper bass output when
comparing the same mfg/model/line of sub. With that said, deep bass
output is highly dependent on how well your subwoofer enclosure is mated
to your subwoofer.

Just keep in mind that not every subwoofer is created equally and some
brands are WAY better than others, except JL Audio. Don't get me wrong,
JL Audio is expensive for a reason and that is because their Quality
Control standards are overboard. I am just saying there are subwoofers
that sound almost as good as JL Audio for a lost less $$!
ChrisB
Posted: Mon Nov 17, 2008 8:04 am
Guest
sims wrote:
Quote:
what companies would you compare to JL? I was interested in them only
since the shop told me to go with them. I am not expierenced with
brands to quality in car audio, but I must say I was impressed with JL.
I was at another place tonight and they sell MTX, rockford, infinity,
and JBL. the salesman recommended the infinity, but also noted his car
is loaded with JL...

If you aren't going with a JL W6, W7, or TW5 series, I would recommend
the RE SE, Fi Q, or Zuki subs in lieu of JL Audio. If you really want
to spend some money, I would recommend the Image Dynamics IDMAX series.

I am not that anti-JL because I run a 13w6v2 in my 2006 Mustang. I also
have a pair of 10w3s that suck royally. Anyone that pays close to MSRP
for the w3 series is getting the biggest pile of crap that JL Audio
produces and the RE, Fi, and Zuki subs will walk all over them!

Check here for the subwoofers I am talking about:

http://reaudio.com/woofers.html#goto_se

https://ssl.perfora.net/www.ficaraudio.com/sess/utn;jsessionid=154914db5ced401/shopdata/0050_Speakers/product_overview.shopscript

http://www.zukiaudio.com/

http://www.imagedynamicsusa.com/products.php?Family_Id=4

I will tell you the main reason I am anti-JL audio though.... That is
because every local custom shop pushes them and pushes them HARD! The
profit margins on JL Audio equipment in general are LARGE and everyone
who drinks the JL Audio kool aid swears that JL is the best, and JL is
far from it, especially for the price!
sims
Posted: Mon Nov 17, 2008 9:51 am
Guest
good to hear!
kinda of like nuance home theatres (which I unfortunatly have, good
speakers WAYYYYY overpriced for what they are)



"ChrisB" <ChrisB@somewhere.someplace.com> wrote in message
news:Z7KdnQfBqcK6Qr3UnZ2dnUVZ_t_inZ2d@giganews.com...
Quote:
sims wrote:
what companies would you compare to JL? I was interested in them only
since the shop told me to go with them. I am not expierenced with brands
to quality in car audio, but I must say I was impressed with JL.
I was at another place tonight and they sell MTX, rockford, infinity, and
JBL. the salesman recommended the infinity, but also noted his car is
loaded with JL...

If you aren't going with a JL W6, W7, or TW5 series, I would recommend the
RE SE, Fi Q, or Zuki subs in lieu of JL Audio. If you really want to
spend some money, I would recommend the Image Dynamics IDMAX series.

I am not that anti-JL because I run a 13w6v2 in my 2006 Mustang. I also
have a pair of 10w3s that suck royally. Anyone that pays close to MSRP
for the w3 series is getting the biggest pile of crap that JL Audio
produces and the RE, Fi, and Zuki subs will walk all over them!

Check here for the subwoofers I am talking about:

http://reaudio.com/woofers.html#goto_se

https://ssl.perfora.net/www.ficaraudio.com/sess/utn;jsessionid=154914db5ced401/shopdata/0050_Speakers/product_overview.shopscript

http://www.zukiaudio.com/

http://www.imagedynamicsusa.com/products.php?Family_Id=4

I will tell you the main reason I am anti-JL audio though.... That is
because every local custom shop pushes them and pushes them HARD! The
profit margins on JL Audio equipment in general are LARGE and everyone who
drinks the JL Audio kool aid swears that JL is the best, and JL is far
from it, especially for the price!
bob wald
Posted: Tue Nov 18, 2008 12:04 am
Guest
go pioneer subs!!!!! almost impossible to beat!
sims
Posted: Tue Nov 18, 2008 8:18 am
Guest
I stopped at another place tonight and they had these
https://www2.visions.ca/catalogue/category/Details.aspx?categoryId=30&productId=1135&menuId=1&parentId1=27&parentId2=%27%27&parentId3=%27%27&menuLevel=2

I was looking to do all 4ohm though


"bob wald" <bob36swmla@webtv.net> wrote in message
news:29513-4921C033-1886@storefull-3311.bay.webtv.net...
Quote:
go pioneer subs!!!!! almost impossible to beat!
ChrisB
Posted: Tue Nov 18, 2008 9:05 am
Guest
sims wrote:

Do you need 4 ohm DVC subs or a 4 ohm final load for a pair of subs?

Contrary to popular belief, these subwoofers are NOT BAD for the price:
http://www.sonicelectronix.com/item_8594_Pioneer+Premier+TS-W1207D4.html
ChrisB
Posted: Tue Nov 18, 2008 9:11 am
Guest
bob wald wrote:
Quote:
go pioneer subs!!!!! almost impossible to beat!

As much as I enjoy arguing with you, I heard a pair of Pioneer 10" subs

a few months back and they surprised the hell out of me! Also, they
were ordered as part of some package from Sonic Electronix where the
subs and the box were a total of $125 shipped or something crazy low
like that.

Kind of reminded me of Coustic subs back in the 90s. I always talked
trash about them until a friend of mine showed up with some and asked me
to make an enclosure for him. He had this huge Sherwood 240 amp that he
used to push those 10" Coustics each in a 1.25 cubic foot sealed box,
and they were LOUD and CLEAN!
sims
Posted: Tue Nov 18, 2008 9:25 am
Guest
wish I could get those prices in canada. after shipping and duty charges it
works out pretty much the same as buying them here.

and I was really surprised with the 12" today at work. a guy pulled into
the work site with the ugliest mustang (newer one, hes smashed it and its
rusting out) I have ever seen. went to talk him and was questioning the
car. he opened the door pull a blanket off where the rear seat should be
and he had dual 12" pioneer premiums each with their own amp, turned the
stereo on low and rattle away. and it didn't sound to bad. unfortunatly he
will need to find a new car as the speakers will out live his ford =)



"ChrisB" <ChrisB@somewhere.someplace.com> wrote in message
news:b76dnf9fqaD33b_UnZ2dnUVZ_uOdnZ2d@giganews.com...
Quote:
bob wald wrote:
go pioneer subs!!!!! almost impossible to beat!

As much as I enjoy arguing with you, I heard a pair of Pioneer 10" subs a
few months back and they surprised the hell out of me! Also, they were
ordered as part of some package from Sonic Electronix where the subs and
the box were a total of $125 shipped or something crazy low like that.

Kind of reminded me of Coustic subs back in the 90s. I always talked
trash about them until a friend of mine showed up with some and asked me
to make an enclosure for him. He had this huge Sherwood 240 amp that he
used to push those 10" Coustics each in a 1.25 cubic foot sealed box, and
they were LOUD and CLEAN!
ChrisB
Posted: Tue Nov 18, 2008 5:22 pm
Guest
sims wrote:
Quote:
wish I could get those prices in canada. after shipping and duty
charges it works out pretty much the same as buying them here.

and I was really surprised with the 12" today at work. a guy pulled
into the work site with the ugliest mustang (newer one, hes smashed it
and its rusting out) I have ever seen. went to talk him and was
questioning the car. he opened the door pull a blanket off where the
rear seat should be and he had dual 12" pioneer premiums each with their
own amp, turned the stereo on low and rattle away. and it didn't sound
to bad. unfortunatly he will need to find a new car as the speakers
will out live his ford =)


I own a rustang myself, 2006, but it isn't rusting, lol! The only
reason I ended up going with the JL Audio Stealthbox is because I was
tired of trying to fit a square peg into a round hole. The trunk
opening on any Mustang since 1996 pretty much sucks, unless you want to
build your box in the trunk.

Also, I travel too much, so ditching the spare is not an option. Ever
get a flat 300 miles away from home? Try finding a replacement BF
Goodrich KDW NT in 235/50-18 300 miles away from home only to be told
that they are a special order item.

I should have just ditched that useless back seat, and I still may end
up doing so.
cdd
Posted: Mon Nov 24, 2008 3:17 am
Guest
On Nov 19, 3:15 am, ChrisB <Chr...@somewhere.someplace.com> wrote:
Quote:
sims wrote:
wish I could get those prices in canada.  after shipping and duty
charges it works out pretty much the same as buying them here.

and I was really surprised with the 12" today at work.  a guy pulled
into the work site with the ugliest mustang (newer one, hes smashed it
and its rusting out) I have ever seen.  went to talk him and was
questioning the car.  he opened the door pull a blanket off where the
rear seat should be and he had dual 12" pioneer premiums each with their
own amp, turned the stereo on low and rattle away.  and it didn't sound
to bad.  unfortunatly he will need to find a new car as the speakers
will out live his ford =)

I own a rustang myself, 2006, but it isn't rusting, lol!  The only
reason I ended up going with the JL Audio Stealthbox is because I was
tired of trying to fit a square peg into a round hole.  The trunk
opening on any Mustang since 1996 pretty much sucks, unless you want to
build your box in the trunk.

Also, I travel too much, so ditching the spare is not an option.  Ever
get a flat 300 miles away from home?  Try finding a replacement BF
Goodrich KDW NT in 235/50-18 300 miles away from home only to be told
that they are a special order item.

I should have just ditched that useless back seat, and I still may end
up doing so.

What do you think of Soundstream- I use the T4 15" subs But real
speakers
require real power!!
GregS
Posted: Mon Nov 24, 2008 5:26 pm
Guest
In article <ad2e00ae-0544-453a-88d1-bcb28eb1578c@41g2000yqf.googlegroups.com>, cdd <annissajury@kol.co.nz> wrote:
Quote:
On Nov 19, 3:15=A0am, ChrisB <Chr...@somewhere.someplace.com> wrote:
sims wrote:
wish I could get those prices in canada. =A0after shipping and duty
charges it works out pretty much the same as buying them here.

and I was really surprised with the 12" today at work. =A0a guy pulled
into the work site with the ugliest mustang (newer one, hes smashed it
and its rusting out) I have ever seen. =A0went to talk him and was
questioning the car. =A0he opened the door pull a blanket off where the
rear seat should be and he had dual 12" pioneer premiums each with thei=
r
own amp, turned the stereo on low and rattle away. =A0and it didn't sou=
nd
to bad. =A0unfortunatly he will need to find a new car as the speakers
will out live his ford =3D)

I own a rustang myself, 2006, but it isn't rusting, lol! =A0The only
reason I ended up going with the JL Audio Stealthbox is because I was
tired of trying to fit a square peg into a round hole. =A0The trunk
opening on any Mustang since 1996 pretty much sucks, unless you want to
build your box in the trunk.

Also, I travel too much, so ditching the spare is not an option. =A0Ever
get a flat 300 miles away from home? =A0Try finding a replacement BF
Goodrich KDW NT in 235/50-18 300 miles away from home only to be told
that they are a special order item.

I should have just ditched that useless back seat, and I still may end
up doing so.

What do you think of Soundstream- I use the T4 15" subs But real
speakers
require real power!!

Inefficient speakers need real power.
Larger speakers tend to be more efficient needing less power.

greg
bob wald
Posted: Thu Nov 27, 2008 7:28 am
Guest
sherwood 240 was the smallest in the xat series..i have the 3400.
actually theres 2 zeros.
ChrisB
Posted: Sat Nov 29, 2008 4:28 am
Guest
bob wald wrote:
Quote:
sherwood 240 was the smallest in the xat series..i have the 3400.
actually theres 2 zeros.

One of the things that my friend could not understand is why my Punch

150 was so much louder on his 10s than his 240 watt Sherwood. I guess I
should have told him that I was friends with the area distributor who
had his Punch 150s modified so that he could cheat in competitions
(lol). Guess who I purchased most of my Punch 150s from....
bob wald
Posted: Thu Dec 04, 2008 12:53 am
Guest
rf...hAHAhahaHA......i just meant theres 2 zeros on its
series...xat2400.
but the xats are 2ohm stable....my Sherwood xat3400 is 85rms to
4ohms/4channels.
yours was 65rms to 4ohms/channels too.
MOSFET
Posted: Sun Dec 21, 2008 7:34 am
Guest
.. I am just saying there are subwoofers
Quote:
that sound almost as good as JL Audio for a lost less $$!


I'll second that. You are partly paying for the JL name and their large PR
and marketing budget. They are great subs; I used a pair of 12W3's for
years several years back and they were outstanding subs, but a bit pricey
for what you can buy today for that same price.

As far as your original question, the larger the subwoofer you get buys you
two major advantages: 1) larger subs are more generally more efifcient
meaning they need less power to produce the same SPL as a smaller sub. This
can be be VERY beneficial if you do not have a large sub amp OR a lot of
extra current from your car's electrical system. 2) the other advantage is
that larger subs can generally play lower frequencies at greater volume than
smaller subs.

HOWEVER, the generally accepted drawback of larger subs is that they are not
as "tight" as smaller subs. This, however, is debatable and depends greatly
on the subs in question. Of course the other drawback is that larger subs
require larger enclosures, thereby you will need to sacrifice more cabin or
trunk space.

I would not necessarily rule out 15" subs either. I recently had a pair of
high-end MTX 7500 12"'s stollen out of my car. I had this unused dual 15"
sealed box just laying around in my garage and decided to buy a pair of low
cost 15's.

To my surprise, I actually like the 15's better than my MTX 12's. They are
MUCH louder as they are more efficient as I mentioned earlier. They also
can play lower than my 12's. As far as "tightness", I don't notice any
difference at all. They sound GREAT!!! If you have the space in your
vehicle, you may want to consider 15's as well. It's safe to say this will
give you the loudest bang for your buck.

MOSFET
 
Page 1 of 1       All times are GMT
The time now is Wed Jan 07, 2009 2:49 am